| A parallel experience to childbirth? Uh, if you loved it. |
My point is not that women win the hard/painful contest, and
it certainly is not that we should be pitied for our sacrifice -- that's the
perspective of the Belly Laughs book that pisses me off so much. We don't deserve to be pitied: we do deserve to
be envied.
Let's entirely
disregard all fodder for martyrdom, all suffering and exertion inherent in
the process of pregnancy and birth. While other experiences may
be more challenging, the experience of creating and sustaining something alive inside
you is weird, trippy, disconcerting -- and heady, hypnotic, absolutely mystic
when you feel movement begin, when you sense excitement in response to Daddy's
voice (or Natural Language Processing as with Amelie). Sparking life inside you and becoming a conduit of consciousness is enviable because it's empowering, exhilarating, and really, really strange -- plus once the baby's out it's deeply gratifying to amplify your influence in the world.
Please do pardon my unscientific digressions. As with being a graduate student, being a mother doesn't get the positive press it deserves (they're both a lot more fun than they seem). We'll be back to opinionless facts next post I promise. For now, happy parenting. Be proud.
Please do pardon my unscientific digressions. As with being a graduate student, being a mother doesn't get the positive press it deserves (they're both a lot more fun than they seem). We'll be back to opinionless facts next post I promise. For now, happy parenting. Be proud.
Envy, yes, I'll give you envy for the closeness you'll have because of childbirth, something not entirely achievable by men. Frankly, all the guy has to do is have a good time, if he wants, then leave. Too many guys do exactly that.
ReplyDeleteI've heard too many times how guys don't have the same experience with pain but pain is universal and we call all experience it. It's become a mantra but it isn't true (though women do have a higher pain threshold in general, according to MythBusters). So, I was riffing on that. And knowing some people who upon tearing other muscles and ligaments say the pain's worse than giving birth.
However, your point is well taken and irrefutable. Let let the silly lady rest and I'll point people to your blog when looking for book advise.
I can see your point in how the relationship forged by gestation is different from others, but you might be surprised (as I was) at how strongly fathers, grandparents and other newborn caretakers (including adoptive/foster ones) are also physiologically influenced by the experience. The next post will describe some of that research. There's really cool stuff going on in your brain too.
DeleteI'm surprised by the blanket statement that carrying a child "deserves envy", a mandate that leaves no room for those who can't carry a child to make any other choice but envy. The power of that statement comes to me as very insensitive to how others live.
ReplyDeleteAs stated (and I know not based in real numbers) "65% of humans don't or can't carry a child". I, for one, did not do anything to foster my ability to carry a child. I was born with this ability. For the non-religious, it was luck of the draw. For the religious, it was Gods Will. I didn't do anything and I don't feel like anyone who can have a child automatically ~Deserves~ anyone's envy. Men and women who can't have children though want to, were just not born with the bits and pieces that they need in order to grow this life. Yes, they may be envious, however, they ~Deserve~ everyone's compassion more than anything else, which I feel the original statement lacks.
The second part that I feel needs to be addressed is the fact that you do not have to birth a baby in order to amplify your influence on the world. I would imagine that creating a family through foster and adoption is just as gratifying. Or teaching, mentoring or creating a connection with a child, whomever they "belong" to. As adults, we have a responsibility to all children to create caring and safe environments, which they will hopefully apply to other children as they age.
Leigh -- instead of pity for those who give birth, having compassion for those who can't -- I like that. You state my point very well, more empathically and precisely than I did. We disagree on one important implication, though: to say that an experience is enviable is not to say those who cannot have the experience have no choice but envy it, no more than saying that Obama's decisions as president are admirable implies that everyone other than Obama has no choice but admire him. We feel what we feel. Personally I believe that people who yearn for and mourn an absence of childbearing in their lives make some of the best parents out there. It'd be interesting to find research on correlations between adoptive status and parental caretaking strategies.
DeleteSimilarly, just as that 65% (or whatever; I still can't find that number) have a panoply of other challenging and fulfilling adventures available, so are there many ways other than physical reproduction to amplify our influence. Expressing charged opinions respectfully is one of them -- thanks for your contribution.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete